Ending maternal and infant food insecurity

Maternal and infant food security is crucial for the health and wellbeing of women and babies. Our research aims to understand the scale and nature of this problem in the UK, and to develop policies and initiatives directed towards ending food insecurity.

Out of Milk: The impact of food insecurity on infant feeding in the UK

Dec 2023 - Oct 2024 | Funder: No funding required | Status: Complete

There has been much public focus on the issue of formula poverty. However, despite international research having explored the impact of poverty on women’s infant feeding experiences in a wider context, little attention has been paid to the impact of food insecurity on infant feeding in the UK.

The aim of this research project was to gather information on whether food insecurity has impacted women’s infant feeding experiences, and to look at some of the factors that influence infant feeding in the UK today. We also sought to gain an understanding of how professionals who work with families are able to support families living in food insecurity with infant feeding , and identify where there may be gaps in understanding.

    • The cost-of-living crisis has impacted on all infant feeding experiences both breastfeeding and formula feeding.

    • Women experiencing food insecurity initiate breastfeeding at a similar rate as food secure women.

    • Women experiencing food insecurity seek infant feeding support at a similar rate to food secure women. Women experiencing food insecurity are more likely to stop breastfeeding than food secure women in part due to concerns over milk quality because of a poor maternal diet.

    • Most women who use formula milk had not planned to. Budgeting for the additional cost of formula milk is adding financial and psychological pressures, disproportionately impacting food insecure families.

    • Some groups face additional barriers with infant feeding including women living with HIV and those with no recourse to public funds.

    • Increase the value of the Healthy Start Scheme and widen the eligibility criteria in line with the free school meal criteria.

    • Work across sectors and with public involvement to build systems, policies and practices to help identify the scale and nature of the impact of food insecurity on infant feeding, and to improve prevention and support for those in need,

    • Take a person-centred approach to infant feeding policies and practices within the antenatal and postnatal periods, recognising the impact of poverty and food insecurity.

    • Promote public health messaging on the nutritional equivalence of all first infant formula milks.

    • Develop a not for profit infant formula milk to address the cost of formula, as well as the wider issues that result in families facing barriers to accessing this vital product.

Access to infant formula for babies living in food poverty in the UK

Oct 2020 - May 2022 | Funder: No funding required | Status: Complete

In 2020 we undertook a comprehensive review of formula access pathways that found families living in food poverty face a postcode lottery when seeking formula for their formula fed babies. Shortly after, we launched this research study to assess the role of food and baby banks in maximising access to formula for formula fed babies in need.

Our key aim was to gain an understanding of the experiences of families who seek support from food and baby banks and the professionals who support them, and to identify key factors that influence accessibility.

  • Food poverty and food insecurity is a major public health concern in the UK

    COVID-19 has exacerbated previously existing inequalities leading to an escalation in food poverty. For children this can be particularly devastating as experiencing childhood poverty has serious long-term effects including reduced life expectancy, poorer health and educational outcomes.

    When families cannot access formula for their formula fed babies, infants may be at risk

    Respondents highlighted their concern that any delay in accessing formula may lead to babies being underfed and provided real life examples of this, in particular, of families having to water down formula. These finding echo those of the All Party Parliamentary Group in Infant Feeding and Inequalities who reported similar in 2018.

    The overwhelming majority of respondents recognise the essential role food and baby banks play in providing formula for formula fed babies experiencing food poverty

    The vast majority of responders (99.3%) stated that food and baby banks are essential for supporting families living in food poverty, and have a vital role to play in the provision of infant formula (91.3%).

    Guidelines that recommend food and baby banks don’t provide formula create barriers to access

    Our data analysis highlighted that current UNICEF UK guidelines that recommend food and baby banks do not directly provide infant formula are causing problems at multiple levels; families face delays in getting formula for their babies, relationships between health care providers and third sector organisations are put under strain and healthcare providers are prevented from accessing support for the babies in their care.

    Alternative routes of access to infant formula are inadequate

    Responders expressed concern about inadequacies of alternate pathways of support (to which UNICEF UK recommend food and baby banks direct families instead of offering formula). Benefit applications take too long, don’t cover costs & aren’t available for all who need support. Furthermore, families often don’t have the means to access additional support pathways.

    Formula can be provided safely at food and baby banks

    Our inquiry found that formula can be provided safely by food/baby banks, alongside referring families to services that offer longer term support. It doesn’t have to be one or the other. There are brilliant initiatives out there plugging the gaps left by the current system to ensure no baby goes hungry. Our guidelines for food and baby banks on infant formula provision can support these organisations to provide first infant formula for formula fed babies experiencing food poverty.

    Food and baby banks are not the answer to formula poverty

    Obviously, food and baby banks are not the answer to formula poverty. We need systemic change. In the meantime, our data shows that we mustn’t limit formula access pathways – these need to be maximised to reduce the risks to formula fed babies caused by delayed access to their main or only food source.

Access to infant formula for babies living in food poverty in the UK

Oct 2020 - May 2022 | Funder: No funding required | Status: Complete

Aware of rising numbers of families living in food poverty, and the associated risks to infants when families can’t afford formula, we undertook a comprehensive review of access to infant formula across the UK.

Our aim was to highlight any barriers or risks associated with the current practice and to provide evidence based recommendations for a way forward. The review highlighted a number of inadequacies with the current provision routes, inequity of access to formula for vulnerable groups, and difficulties faced by some third sector organisations due to inadequate guidelines. Together this has resulted in a post code lottery of infant formula provision across the country meaning some babies are going without.

Our recommendations pave the way to addressing the inequity faced by formula feeding families living in poverty in accessing formula for their babies.

  • Food poverty is a serious issue and the incidence is rising across Scotland and the rest of the UK

    • The number of families experiencing food poverty has significantly increased over the course of the Covid-19 pandemic with households with children being the hardest hit.

    • Health & social care professionals are ideally placed to recognise need and should be facilitated to signpost families to the relevant support services.

    Infant formula provides the main, or sole source of nutrition for the majority of babies in Scotland

    • In Scotland only 72% of babies in the most deprived areas are formula fed. Infant formula is the only food formula fed babies can have for the first six months of their lives

    • First infant formula is expensive, costing up to £30 a week for an exclusively formula fed infant of around four months of age.

    • Families report being unable to afford sufficient formula and lack of direct access results in increased risk to the caregiver and the infant.

    • Inappropriate feeding practices have immediate, short term and long term health consequences, and increase the divide in socio-demographic health inequalities.

    Specific groups are particularly vulnerable

    • Formula feeding families living in areas of greater deprivation.

    • Families who have no recourse to public funds cannot access many of the current routes of infant formula provision.

    • British HIV Association guidance recommends exclusive formula feeding as a means of preventing vertical transmission of HIV. However, many women living with HIV find themselves unable to access sufficient infant formula.

    • Infants with a drug using parent are at risk of separation from their parents. Kinship carers are frequently of low income with 72% reporting financial hardship due to undertaking caring roles.

    UNICEF UK guidelines for food and baby banks recommend against direct provision of infant formula, thus creating barriers to access for babies in need of food

    • International guidelines and UK law allow for formula provision, yet UNICEF UK recommend food and baby banks do not provide formula for formula fed babies living in food poverty.

    • There is significant variation in the interpretation of these guidelines, resulting in friction between health and social care providers and third sector organisations, and a post code lottery with regards to formula provision.

    • The guidelines create inequality of access for families living in poverty in the UK and thus don’t safeguard formula fed babies in poverty.

    • The absence of safe guidance creates risk and result in a time delay in accessing formula for hungry babies.

    • The guidelines confuse the immediate need for food with a requirement for longer term infant feeding support or financial support.

    • The guidelines recommend monetary provision in an emergency but food banks aren’t set up for this & money introduces additional risk. It is unclear how monetary provision negates risk or meets the requirement for consistency of supply.

    • The guidelines do not state which stakeholders were consulted in their development to ensure they are fit for purpose and are not explicit regarding conflict of interest. UNICEF UK’s Baby Friendly Initiative states a primary aim of promoting and protecting breastfeeding, and accreditation involves a financial transaction.

    Current pathways for emergency access to formula are inadequate

    • Many local authorities do not have a formula provision pathway, and of those who do, over 60% rely on referrals to food banks.

    Suggested financial provision routes have limitations

    • Many food and baby banks do not have the infrastructure to provide cash, and there are concerns regarding monetary provision.

    • Healthy Start or Best Start voucher schemes are not enough to cover the cost of infant formula and applications can take weeks to process. Vouchers are only available to pregnant women, so Fathers or other caregivers are ineligible and the scheme is not open to families with No Recourse to Public Funds.

    • Additional emergency funding schemes - section 22, Scottish Welfare Fund and Scottish Child Payment - can take time to access, and are not open to everyone.

    Food and baby banks are a vital source of infant formula for formula fed babies living in food poverty

    • Staff and volunteers can meet the immediate need for food alongside signposting families to relevant services for long term support.

    • Food and baby banks can provide first infant formula and NHS literature on safe formula feeding.

    Maximising routes of access to infant formula is crucial for ensuring equity and minimising the delay in access to food for hungry babies.

    1. The government must take immediate action to clarify the current law on the provision of infant formula from food and baby banks.

    2. Food and baby banks and other such services should accept and provide First Infant Formula to parents and carers of formula fed babies up to one year of age.

    3. The Government must take immediate action to remove current barriers to formula access.

    4. The government must continue to invest in longer term solutions to child food poverty.

    5. Guidance should allow for safe direct provision of first infant formula for formula fed babies in need and ensure equity of access for all.

Publications

Research Reports  

  • McNee R, Murphy C and Williams EJ. (2024) Out of Milk: The impact of food insecurity on infant feeding in the UK. Feed Report; Oct 2024.

  • McNee R, Williams EJ, Maia S and Walker K. (2022) Access to infant formula for babies living in food poverty in the UK: An investigation of the role of food and baby banks. Feed Report; May 2022 

  • McNee R, Williams, EJ, Maia S and Walker K. (2020) The provision of infant formula at food banks in the UK: Ensuring a fair for all approach to protect the health and wellbeing of formula fed infants and their families. Feed Review; Dec 2020

Research-Based Policy & Guidance   

  • Scottish Government (2024). Guide to Responding to and Preventing Infant Food Insecurity in Scotland. Scottish Government Policy, Feb 2024. (McNee R and Williams EJ, Co-authors). 

  • McNee R and Williams EJ. (2024) Helping families who need infant formula: guidance for food and baby banks. Feed Guidance, Feb 2024

  • McNee R, Maia S, Wishart K and Williams EJ. (2019) Provision of infant formula: guidance for food and baby banks. Feed Guidance, May 2019 - Feb 2024.

Conference Contributions   

  • McNee R, Flecher-Horne D, Athanopolous P, Fenton L, Douglas F, Frank L and Williams EJ (2024). Ending infant food insecurity: how do we gather routine data on something people are fearful to disclose? Society for Social Medicine and Public Health Annual Conference, Sep 24. Workshop.

  • McNee R, Murphy C and Williams EJ (2024). Infant feeding and the cost-of-living crisis: an investigation of the impact of food insecurity on infant feeding in the UK. Scotland Public Health Conference. May 24.

  • McNee R and Williams EJ. (2023) Securing the right to food for infants: exploring the lived experience of families with infants in accessing formula milk. RCPCH Conference – Child Health in a Changing World; Archives of Disease in Childhood; 108:A82. 

  • McNee RE, Hetherington L, Frank L, Douglas F and Williams EJ. (2023) A scoping review of infant food insecurity in Forth Valley: challenges of breastfeeding and formula feeding when food insecure. British Medical Association Public Health Medicine Conference 2023: Tackling Twenty-First Century Poverty, March 2023. 

  • McNee R and Williams EJ. (2021) When Policy creates inequality: review and development of foodbank guidelines. Women’s Medical Federation Spring Conference, May 2021. 

Invited Presentations 

  • McNee R, Murphy C and Williams EJ. (2024) Out of Milk: The impact of household food insecurity on breastfeeding in UK mothers. Nourishing Futures Network Annual Conference 2024, Oct 2024.

  • McNee R and Williams EJ. (2023) Infant feeding and food insecurity: securing the Right to Food for all. Parenting culture and feeding babies: a one-day symposium, University of Kent, May 2023. 

  • McNee R, Maia S, Wishart K and Williams EJ. (2022) Securing the right to food: addressing maternal and infant food insecurity in Scotland. All Party Parliamentary Group on Infant Feeding and Inequalities, February 7th 2023.    

  • McNee R, Williams EJ, Frank L and Douglas F. (2022) Securing the right to food: addressing maternal and infant food insecurity in Scotland. Scottish Government Joint Poverty and Inequalities Commission & Children’s Commission Quarterly Meeting, October 5th 2022.   

Letters and Responses   

  • McNee R and Williams EJ. (2022) Rising cost of living’s effect on infant feeding. BMJ 2022;377:o1459  doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.o1459 Published 15 June 2022. Letter of the Week. 

  • McNee R, Maia S, Wishart K and Williams EJ. (2020) Food banks and formula: maximising support for families in need. BMJ 2020;371:m4841. doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.m4841. Published 18 December 2020. Rapid Response. 

  • McNee R, Maia S, Wishart K and Williams EJ. (2020) Re: Food banks and infant formula: who knows best? BMJ 2020;371:m4449. doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.m4449 Published 16 November 2020. Rapid Response. 

  • McNee R, Maia S, Wishart K, Murphy C, Gold D, Flecher-Horn D and Williams EJ. (2020). Re: Fears grow of nutritional crisis in lockdown UK. BMJ 2020;370:m3193. doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.m3193 Published 20 August 2020. Rapid Response. 

  • Williams EJ, Maia S, McNee R, Wishart K, Murphy C and Cannon E. (2019) Reducing the environmental impact of formula must not jeopardise women’s reproductive rights. BMJ 2019;367:l6328. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.l6328 Published 06 November 2019. Rapid Response. 

Watch Erin's presentation at the Parenting Culture and Feeding Babies symposium, held at the University of Kent, 25 May 2023. Erin's presentation starts at 25 minutes.

Research-Based Policy and Guidance

Let’s work together

Coming together to share our individual ideas, expertise and perspectives makes for really fruitful research projects. Please get in touch if you are interested in collaborating, have an idea or suggestion for a research topic, would like to ask a question, or just want to chat infant feeding science!